by Johnny
This is several days old, but not covered here. MTV News broke the story about a new study that concludes that Harry Potter, big surprise, can be addictive:
They surveyed fans before the book’s release, upon completion of the book and six months afterwards as a follow-up. The 10 percent of respondents that Rudski considers addicted described spending more than four hours a day on Potter-related activities, experiencing interference with appetite and sleep patterns, engaging in less physical activity, having a lower sense of well-being and being more irritable after completing the series.
“Some readers can become so engaged in the series and the ancillary world that grew out of it that they report behaviors that truly fit definitions of addiction or dependence,” the synopsis of his draft reads.
One of the contributing factors is the fan community itself and is a “blurry” one because “it’s harder to draw the line between fandom and compulsion.” However the study shows that an addiction to Harry Potter is not all bad:
Likewise, Rudski’s subjects didn’t all turn their addictions into negative forces, but he found that those who were the most creative with their fandom showed the least disruption to their personal lives, addicted or not. For instance, those he calls the “core” fans, who read the books and liked to theorize, had the greatest amount of withdrawal symptoms. Online community fans, however, showed more of an intermediate level of withdrawal after reading the last book, but six months afterwards, still reported continued disruption (as opposed to core fans, who moved on). And for those who turned Harry Potter into a creative outlet — either through fan fiction, fan art or wizard rock — didn’t show hardly any withdrawal symptoms at all, though they continued to spend just as much time engaged in those activities as they did before. What does that tell us? “It’s more like a caffeine addiction,” Rudski said. “The withdrawal can be over, but the addiction is still there.”
What do you think?






1 response so far ↓
1 LunaLouise
// Feb 24, 2008 at 3:24 pm
‘[T]hose he calls the “core” fans, who read the books and liked to theorize, had the greatest amount of withdrawal symptoms. Online community fans, however, showed more of an intermediate level of withdrawal after reading the last book, but six months afterwards, still reported continued disruption (as opposed to core fans, who moved on).’
I think we can all say that we belong in the core fan group when it comes to his categorisation. I do have to say that I did experience withdrawal-like symptoms (no as severe as not being able to eat or sleep though). I absolutely experienced that big gaping black hole feeling after finishing the book. But fortunately I had other readers irl and online to talk with. I agree that when considering readers with varying levels of addictive traits, it probably will have been easier for people with communities to cope with the big black hole. Purely because the community functions as a support group.
For me the experience was completely positive though in the end. I think for me personally the reason why I started to display addictive behaviour towards Harry Potter is because this for me is the single one series that has really gotten me into literature. My first real literature love I guess I can say.
How about the rest of you ?
Leave a Comment